My dogs have always loved these treats. When I trained my dogs at 6 weeks to use the bathroom outside. It was winter and cold and I would always tell him if he went potty he would get a Beggin strip. Then when we got inside I would walk over to the bag and touch it and he would get all excited for his treat. I would recommend these to use as a training treat. You will not regret it! Also for small dogs I broke the treat in half.